It just happened. So we called it Serendipity.

A family, a market stall, and a lot of cookies nobody planned on.

It started at a market stall

In 2023, Linda McKenzie was working for a vendor at the St. Jacobs Market and had the idea of baking some cookies to sell at the stall. They really flew.

None of the family had a baking background. Linda is a retired teacher; her son Justin has a background in business. But once they started, they loved the creativity and the science of it, and the cookies kept selling.

“We didn’t plan on starting a cookie company. It just evolved and happened. That’s why we called it Serendipity.”

Linda McKenzie, speaking to EloraFergusToday in March 2026
Two of the family behind the Serendipity stall at the Elora Summer Market, chalkboard flavour tags in the case and the red banner below
Behind the stall at the Elora Summer Market, June 2025.
A baker with her arms in the air at the end of a long table of sheet pans covered in lattice-topped apple pie cookies
Our first wedding: more than 100 Apple Pie cookies, each packaged and labelled.

From a shared kitchen to Geddes Street

Linda had moved to Elora from Mississauga, and for a while the family baked out of a commercial kitchen in Guelph while they looked for a home for the shop. It took about a year and a half. Just when it seemed it might not happen, they spotted a for-sale sign in a window on Geddes Street and decided to take the leap.

The shop opened in March 2026. Linda keeps the case full, Justin brings the business know-how, and Dad, Tenny, is often behind the counter on weekends. The coffee comes from Elora Coffee Roasters.

A new six every month

The menu changes every month: six new flavours, a few old favourites coming back, and the regulars that stay put, like the pie cookies. Our apple pie cookie, with its lattice crust over a sugar cookie, was inspired by the apple farms of Wellington County and Woolwich and the St. Jacobs apple fritter.

We bake with Belgian chocolate and locally sourced dairy, and every cookie is finished by hand.

A chocolate cookie topped with a rose of caramel buttercream and brownie crumble
A rose of caramel buttercream and brownie crumble.

Ready for a little box of happy?

Pick three, six or twelve. Mix them any way you like.

Your cart