Your next happy little discovery.

Handmade gourmet cookies in Elora, with familiar favourites and delicious surprises.

157 Geddes Street, Elora · a new lineup every month

Six new flavours every month, a few regulars that never leave, and all of it made by hand.

November menu

We’re a 100% peanut-free shop.

Any other allergy or dietary need? Call 647-400-1887 before you order and we’ll go through what’s in each cookie. Allergy questions

See every cookie, and what we’ve made before

A baker with her arms in the air at the end of a long table of sheet pans covered in lattice-topped apple pie cookies
More than 100 Apple Pie cookies, packed for a wedding.
Close-up of the apple pie cookie’s woven lattice

St. Jacob’s Apple Pie

A sugar cookie, a layer of apple pie filling, and a hand-woven lattice crust on top.

It’s the cookie people ask for by name. The idea came from close to home: the apple farms of Wellington County and Woolwich, and the apple fritters at the St. Jacobs market where Serendipity started.

On top
Lattice pie crust, woven by hand
Inside
Apple pie filling
Underneath
Our sugar cookie base

One of the regulars. Menus change, so ask what’s in the case when you visit.

Good things come by the box.

Choose a size, then fill it. Doubles welcome. Open the full box builder

Three of the family smiling in the Serendipity market stall above the red banner
At the Elora Summer Market stall, 2025.

We didn’t plan on a cookie company.

In 2023, Linda was working at a vendor’s stall at the St. Jacobs Market and baked some cookies to sell at the counter. They flew. Her son Justin brought the business sense, Dad pitched in on weekends, and the family kept baking.

None of them had a baking background. It just happened, which is how it got its name. In March 2026 the McKenzies opened their first shop, on Geddes Street in Elora.

Read our story

Come say hi on Geddes Street.

157 Geddes StreetElora, OntarioN0B 1S0

Hours change with the seasons, so we keep them up to date on Instagram. Making a special trip? Call ahead.

A White Chocolate Biscoff cookie held up in tongs against the shop window’s cookie decal
157 Geddes St.

Good to know

Where is the shop?

At 157 Geddes Street in downtown Elora, Ontario (N0B 1S0), a short walk from the Grand River. Directions and contact details.

When are you open?

We post our current hours on Instagram (opens in a new tab). If you’re making a special trip, give us a call at 647-400-1887 first.

How often does the menu change?

Every month. A new lineup of six flavours arrives at the start of the month, alongside a few regulars like our St. Jacob’s Apple Pie. Each month’s flavours go up on our Instagram, and when a month ends, its flavours go too (though old favourites do come back).

Can I mix flavours in a box?

Yes. Cookies are $5 each, and boxes come in 3 ($14), 6 ($25) or 12 ($48). Mix them however you like, doubles and triples of a favourite included. Build a box.

Do you have allergy or dietary information?

Our shop is 100% peanut free.

For any other allergy or dietary need, please call us at 647-400-1887 before you order if you have an allergy or a dietary need. The menu changes every month, so we’d rather talk you through exactly what’s in each cookie than guess.

More questions and answers

Ready for a little box of happy?

Pick three, six or twelve. Mix them any way you like.

Your cart