Good to know
Short answers to the questions we hear most at the counter.
Where is the shop?
At 157 Geddes Street in downtown Elora, Ontario (N0B 1S0), a short walk from the Grand River. Directions and contact details.
When are you open?
We post our current hours on Instagram (opens in a new tab). If you’re making a special trip, give us a call at 647-400-1887 first.
Can I mix flavours in a box?
Yes. Cookies are $5 each, and boxes come in 3 ($14), 6 ($25) or 12 ($48). Mix them however you like, doubles and triples of a favourite included. Build a box.
Can I order online?
Yes, for pickup. Build a box or add single cookies, choose a pickup time (between 10 am and 4 pm, with at least 30 minutes’ notice) and place your order. There’s nothing to pay online: you pay in the shop when you pick up. We’ll have it boxed and waiting for you at 157 Geddes Street. For delivery, order through Uber Eats (opens in a new tab). You can also come into the shop or call 647-400-1887.
What if a flavour sells out?
When a flavour runs out, we mark it sold out on the website right away, so it can’t be added to a new order. If it runs out after you’ve already ordered, we’ll call or text you before your pickup so you can swap it for another flavour.
Do you have allergy or dietary information?
Our shop is 100% peanut free.
For any other allergy or dietary need, please call us at 647-400-1887 before you order if you have an allergy or a dietary need. The menu changes every month, so we’d rather talk you through exactly what’s in each cookie than guess.
Do you make cookie cakes or bigger orders?
Yes. Our 8-inch chocolate chip cookie cakes are $25, or $30 with custom writing, and other buttercreams and toppings are available on request. We’ve also done larger orders for events, including more than 100 individually packaged Apple Pie cookies for a wedding. Email info@serendipitycookies.ca, message us on Instagram or come into the shop to plan yours.
What goes into your cookies?
Every cookie is made by hand. We bake with high-quality ingredients like Belgian chocolate and locally sourced dairy, and our pie cookies get a real lattice crust over the filling.
Do you have coffee?
We pour coffee from our neighbours at Elora Coffee Roasters, which is very good with a cookie.
Do you deliver or ship?
For delivery, order through Uber Eats (opens in a new tab). Otherwise, order online for pickup or visit the shop on Geddes Street. If you’re planning something bigger or farther away, call or message us and we’ll tell you what’s possible.
Ready for a little box of happy?
Pick three, six or twelve. Mix them any way you like.