A baker with her arms in the air at the end of a long table of sheet pans covered in lattice-topped apple pie cookies

St. Jacob’s Apple Pie

Sugar cookie, apple pie filling, a lattice crust on top.

A regular

Our best-known cookie. It starts with a sugar cookie base, gets a layer of apple pie filling, and finishes under a hand-woven lattice of pie crust.

The idea came from close to home: the apple farms of Wellington County and the Township of Woolwich, and the apple fritters at the St. Jacobs market where Serendipity began.

Ingredients and allergens

Our shop is 100% peanut free. We haven’t listed full ingredients for this cookie online yet. Call 647-400-1887 or ask at the counter and we’ll go through exactly what’s in it.

You might also like

The whole menu

Your cart